FDA: Close the Secret Food Additive Loophole

No chemicals in our food until proven safe

By submitting this form, I agree to the terms of Consumer Reports' Privacy Policy and User Agreement.

Most Americans assume the FDA checks the safety of every ingredient in our food. It doesn't. For decades, a legal loophole has let companies decide on their own that a new ingredient is safe, then add it to food without FDA review, sometimes without even telling the agency. An estimated 1,000 of these secret additives may already be in the U.S. food supply.

The FDA has now proposed a rule requiring companies to notify the agency about these ingredients. But a Consumer Reports analysis found the proposal leaves the biggest gaps wide open. It doesn't require safety review before a new chemical goes on sale. It lets companies register secret additives already in our food without submitting safety data. It lets products stay on the market even when companies ignore the rule. And it lets companies hide health and safety data from the public by labeling it confidential.

The FDA is taking public comments until December 9, 2026. This is our chance to push for a rule that truly protects families. Sign now and tell the FDA: close the loophole for real, and make companies prove their ingredients are safe before they reach our plates.

Petition to the FDA:

The Food and Drug Administration has a responsibility to ensure the safety of the U.S. food supply. The agency's proposal to end voluntary notification for self-affirmed food ingredients recognizes a long-standing problem: companies have been able to add substances to food without FDA review, and an estimated 1,000 such substances may be in commerce today without the agency's knowledge. The proposal's own account of this history, including deficient safety analyses and ingredients that stay on the market after the agency halts its review, makes a persuasive case for reform.

But as written, the proposed rule would preserve the core weaknesses of the current system. Notification alone is not a safety review. Americans deserve a food system that is safe, transparent and accountable.

We urge the FDA to strengthen the final rule by requiring safety review and safety data submission before new or existing ingredients reach the market, enforcing compliance with real market consequences, and keeping all health and safety data transparent and accessible to the public.

Finally, we urge the agency to secure the staffing and resources needed to carry out meaningful review. A rule the agency cannot implement will not protect anyone.